Railroad Safety & Compliance

Rail Flaw Detection Records Under 49 CFR 213.241: What a Rail Test Report Must Contain

Two-unit rail flaw detection car standing on ballasted track, the kind of test vehicle whose runs produce internal rail inspection records
Photo: GTC-80J 03823@SPK (20260929152606) by N509FZ, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped; this version is shared under the same license.

Under 49 CFR 213.241, a track owner must keep a record of every internal rail inspection that states six things, from the date and the track tested to the location of any track not tested, and must keep it for at least two years after the inspection and one year after the initial remedial action.

A note on the text. The rule wording below was read on November 11, 2026. The section's amendment line ends at 85 FR 63390 (October 7, 2020), so it has not changed since the 2020 rule. Check the current text of 49 CFR 213.241 on eCFR before writing it into a contract.

What does 49 CFR 213.241 require?

49 CFR 213.241 is the inspection records section of the FRA Track Safety Standards: it makes the track owner keep a record of each inspection that Subpart F requires, and it sets the contents, retention, access and electronic-record conditions for those records. The duty sits with the owner, whoever performs the inspection:

"Each owner of track to which this part applies shall keep a record of each inspection required to be performed on that track under this subpart." (49 CFR 213.241(a))

The section has ten paragraphs, and four of them, (c) to (f), speak only about rail testing.

ParagraphSubjectApplies to
(a)The owner keeps a record of each Subpart F inspectionAll inspections
(b)Contents, same-day preparation, signature and location of recordsInspections under 213.4, 213.119, 213.233 and 213.235
(c)The six items of an internal rail inspection recordInternal rail inspections required by 213.237
(d)Retention of the paragraph (c) recordInternal rail inspections
(e)Records behind the service failure rateSegments with a 213.237(a) target
(f)Contents and retention of continuous rail test recordsContinuous testing under 213.240
(g)Records of continuous testing operations, available to FRAOwners who elect continuous testing
(h)Records stay available to the inspectors and to later inspectorsAll inspections
(i)Inspection and copying by FRA on requestAll inspections
(j)Six conditions for electronic recordsAll records under the section

A testing contractor is bound too. Under 49 CFR 213.5(f), any person "including a contractor for a railroad or track owner" who performs a function the part requires must perform it in accordance with the part. The record still belongs to the owner. For how the section sits among the other rules, see the guide to the FRA track safety standards.

Key takeaway: 213.241 is an owner's duty with ten paragraphs, and a rail test record has to satisfy (c), (d), (h), (i) and, when it is electronic, (j).

Which inspections does 213.241 cover, and what does each record need?

The section covers three kinds of record: visual track inspections, internal rail inspections and continuous rail tests, and each has its own content list and retention period. Paragraph (b)'s rules for visual inspections do not carry over to rail tests word for word.

Visual inspections, 213.241(b)Internal rail inspections, 213.241(c)–(d)Continuous rail tests, 213.241(f)
Inspections covered213.4 (excepted track), 213.119 (CWR), 213.233 (track), 213.235 (switches, crossings and similar)Those required by 213.237Those run under 213.240
ContentsAuthor, type of track, date and location, location and nature of any deviation, remedial action by the inspectorThe six items of (c)The 213.240(e) suspect report, the purpose of the test, run and suspect times, and the verified result
When prepared"on the day the inspection is made"Not stated in (c); 72 hours to start storage if electronicNot stated; 72 hours to start storage if electronic
Signature"signed or otherwise certified by the person making the inspection"Not stated in (c); electronic records need a unique author identityNot stated; same electronic condition
RetentionAt least one year after the inspectionAt least two years after the inspection and one year after initial remedial actionThe same two periods, "whichever is later"

Track in Classes 6 to 9 has its own records section, 49 CFR 213.369, which mirrors 213.241. Its rail record paragraph is shorter, and retention is the same two years and one year.

Key takeaway: the same-day and signature wording belongs to visual inspection records; a rail test record is governed by its own six-item list.

What must an internal rail inspection record contain under 213.241(c)?

Paragraph (c) lists six items that every record of an internal rail inspection required by 213.237 "shall specify". The list dates from the 2014 rail integrity rule, which FRA wrote to answer a DOT Inspector General recommendation that railroads report "all track locations (milepost numbers or track miles) covered during internal rail flaw testing" (79 FR 4234, section-by-section analysis of 213.241).

ItemRule textWhat it means in practice
(1)"Date of inspection"Each test date, not the report date
(2)"Track inspected, including beginning and end points"Track number or name and the milepost limits of each run
(3)"Location and type of defects found under § 213.113"Milepost or other locator, which rail, and the defect type as 213.113 names it
(4)"Size of defects found under § 213.113, if not removed prior to the next train movement"The size in the units the remedial action table uses
(5)"Initial remedial action taken and the date thereof"The first action applied, and its date
(6)"Location of any track not tested pursuant to § 213.237(g)"Every length where the operator could not make a valid search

Items (1) and (2): when and where

The date and the limits fix which inspection the record proves. The limits should match the rail inspection segments the owner designated under 213.237(b), because the 370-day and tonnage clocks in 213.237(c) run by segment. A subdivision name without mileposts does not give beginning and end points.

Items (3) and (4): what was found

Defect types come from 49 CFR 213.113, which defines 16 rail defects in paragraph (d). A record that says "head defect" leaves the owner to guess which row of the remedial action table applies.

Size is required only when the defective rail stays in track past the next train movement, the case in which size decides the remedial action. Transverse-type defects are sized as a percentage of the existing rail head cross-sectional area, and length-sized defects such as bolt hole cracks and split heads in inches, so the record should carry the same units. Our guide to FRA rail defect codes covers the defect names.

Item (5): the owner's entry

"Initial remedial action taken and the date thereof" is the one item a testing contractor often cannot complete. Under 213.113(a), a person designated under 213.7 decides whether the track may stay in use, and the owner applies the action. If the test crew has left before that happens, the record is not complete until the owner fills in item (5).

Item (6): what was not tested

Under 49 CFR 213.237(g), if the qualified operator decides a valid search could not be made over a length of track, that length "may not be considered as internally inspected". The owner then has three choices under 213.237(h) before the time or tonnage limit runs out: make a valid search, hold trains to 25 mph, or replace the rail.

Lost coupling or an equipment fault creates such lengths. They are untested rail, not false calls. The 49 CFR 213.237 guide explains the valid-search definition and the test intervals.

Key takeaway: four of the six items describe the test, one is the owner's decision, and one lists the rail the test did not cover.

What extra records does continuous rail testing need?

An owner that uses continuous rail testing under 213.240 must keep the paragraph (f) record, which adds the purpose of the test and a set of dates and times that a stop-and-verify record does not need. The 2020 rule added this paragraph when it wrote continuous testing into Part 213.

In a continuous test the vehicle does not stop to verify each indication; an analyst reviews the data, and a qualified operator verifies each suspect location in the field later. Under 213.241(f) the record must:

  1. include all information required under 213.240(e), which is the systematic listing of suspect locations
  2. state whether the test is being run to satisfy the internal rail inspection requirement of 213.237
  3. list the dates and times of data collection, "including the date and time of the start and end of the test run, and the date and time each suspect location was identified and field-verified"
  4. give the determination after field verification: the location and type of defect found, its size, and the initial remedial action, if required, with its date
  5. be retained for at least two years after the inspection and at least one year after initial remedial action, "whichever is later"

The times matter because 49 CFR 213.240(e) gives 84 hours from the indication to verify a suspect location, and 36 hours where the suspected defect would need remedial action A, A2 or B. A suspect not verified in time must be protected with the most restrictive remedial action for its suspected type and size.

Paragraph (g) of 213.241 also requires records of all continuous testing operations "sufficient for monitoring and determining compliance". Our comparison of continuous and stop-and-verify rail testing covers the method choice.

Key takeaway: a continuous test record is a timeline, and the 84-hour and 36-hour windows are checked against it.

How long must rail inspection records be kept?

A record of an internal rail inspection must be kept for at least two years after the inspection and for one year after the initial remedial action; a visual inspection record must be kept for at least one year. Paragraph (d) sets the rail figure in one sentence:

"The track owner shall retain a rail inspection record under paragraph (c) of this section for at least two years after the inspection and for one year after initial remedial action is taken." (49 CFR 213.241(d))

Both conditions must be met, so the record is kept to the later of the two dates. Paragraph (f)(5) says so in words for continuous tests ("whichever is later").

RecordMinimum retentionParagraph
Visual inspection (213.4, 213.119, 213.233, 213.235)One year after the inspection(b)
Internal rail inspectionTwo years after the inspection and one year after initial remedial action(d)
Continuous rail testThe same two periods, whichever is later(f)(5)
Class 6 to 9 rail inspectionTwo years after the inspection and one year after remedial action213.369(c)

In practice the two-year condition controls. Initial remedial action follows a verified defect within hours, so the one-year condition would matter only if that action came more than a year after the test.

FRA explained in the 2014 preamble why it wants the records held this long: "This information is vital for FRA to determine compliance with the rail integrity and inspection requirements in § 213.113 and § 213.237" (79 FR at about 4251). Both are minimums.

Key takeaway: plan on two years from the test date for every rail test record, and check the remedial action date only in the rare case of a late action.

What are the conditions for electronic records?

An owner may create, retain, transmit, store and retrieve records electronically if the system meets six conditions in 213.241(j). The paragraph applies to every record under the section, visual and rail alike.

ConditionRule wording (shortened)What to check
(j)(1)The system "meets all requirements and contains the information required under this subpart"Every (c) item has a field, including untested track
(j)(2)The owner "monitors its electronic records database to ensure record accuracy"Someone audits the records; the vendor doing so is not the owner doing so
(j)(3)The system uniquely identifies the author; "No two persons shall have the same electronic identity"No shared logins
(j)(4)Each record "cannot be modified in any way, or replaced, once the record is completed"Completed records are locked
(j)(5)Storage "shall be initiated by the person making the inspection within 72 hours following the completion of that inspection"A time stamp shows when storage began
(j)(6)Any amendment is "stored apart from the record which it amends" and identifies the person making itCorrections are separate, attributed entries

Two points catch owners out. The files inside a flaw detector are not automatically a 213.241 record, because an instrument rarely gives each operator a unique identity or locks a completed file; our article on replacing a rail flaw detector covers that problem.

The second point is the 72 hours. It runs from completion of the inspection, and the "person making the inspection" must initiate storage, so an owner who relies on a contractor's system should write that step into the contract.

Key takeaway: an electronic rail test record needs a unique author, a lock on completion, a 72-hour start and separate amendments.

Who signs the record, and who can see it?

Paragraph (b) requires visual inspection records to be "signed or otherwise certified by the person making the inspection"; paragraph (c) names no signer for rail test records, and paragraphs (h) and (i) set who may see any record.

FRA added "or otherwise certified" in 2020. The preamble says the change was "meant to clarify that a record does not have to be physically signed by the person making the inspection", provided the method chosen identifies that person accurately and securely (85 FR 63362, discussion of 213.241).

For a rail test, the people behind the record hold two different qualifications. The operator who decides whether a search was valid and interprets the equipment must be a qualified operator under 49 CFR 213.238. The person who decides whether track with a defect stays in use is designated under 213.7. A good record names both.

Access runs three ways:

  • The inspectors. Records "shall be kept available to persons who performed the inspections and to persons performing subsequent inspections of the track segment" (213.241(h)).
  • FRA. The owner must make records "available for inspection and copying by FRA upon request during regular business hours following reasonable notice" (213.241(i)). The section does not require filing them with FRA.
  • A designated location. Paragraph (b) makes the owner designate where originals are kept, and one location within 100 miles of each state it operates in where copies can be viewed after 10 days' notice from FRA. That sentence sits in the paragraph on visual inspection records, so treat it as a visual-record rule and rely on (i) for rail test records.

The 2014 preamble adds a practical detail: FRA agreed that requests for rail inspection records would come from a designated FRA Rail Integrity Specialist to a contact person named by each owner, and said it intended to put that approach in its compliance manual guidance.

Falsifying a record is a separate matter. Under 49 CFR 213.15(b), a person who "knowingly and willfully falsifies a record or report required by this part may be subject to criminal penalties under 49 U.S.C. 21311".

Key takeaway: the rail record has no named signer in the rule, but it must be open to the next inspector and to FRA on request.

Which rail testing records sit outside 213.241?

Several records that an FRA inspector may ask for after a rail test are required by other sections, and a 213.241(c) report does not contain them.

RecordSectionWho keeps it
Rail inspection segment designations and any FRA-approved changes213.237(b)Track owner
Service failure rate calculation for each segment with a target213.237(a), 213.241(e)Track owner
Notice to FRA within 45 days if the service failure rate target was not achieved213.237(d)Track owner
Operator qualification: name, equipment type, date qualified, date of last reevaluation213.238(e)The operator's employer
Training programs, recorded examinations, proficiency and authorization records213.238(g)The operator's employer, at a designated location
Type of test designated before the run (continuous or stop-and-verify)213.240(c)Track owner
Qualification of continuous-test data analysts213.240(d)(2)The analyst's employer
Annual continuous testing report, within 45 days after each calendar year213.240(g)Track owner, sent to FRA
Designations of persons qualified to inspect track and supervise repairs213.7(e)Track owner

The service failure rate record in 213.241(e) is the owner's own calculation; a contractor's test report cannot supply it, because it depends on broken rails found between tests. The annual report in 213.240(g) is the only document in this list sent to FRA as a matter of course, and it applies only to owners that use continuous testing.

Key takeaway: operator qualification records belong to the testing provider under 213.238, and the service failure rate record belongs to the owner alone.

What should a rail flaw detection report contain?

A rail flaw detection report should carry the six 213.241(c) items as fixed fields, the owner's entry for remedial action, and the supporting information that shows each search was valid. The rule prescribes no form. The layout below marks each field as required by the rule or as good practice an owner can require by contract.

Section of the reportFieldBasis
1. HeaderTrack owner; testing provider; report numberGood practice
Date of each test day213.241(c)(1)
Type of test: stop-and-verify or continuous213.240(c)
2. Track inspectedTrack name or number; beginning and end mileposts of each run213.241(c)(2)
Rail inspection segment the run belongs toGood practice (ties to 213.237(b))
Turnouts, crossovers and sidings included or excludedGood practice
3. Track not testedEach length without a valid search, by milepost and rail, with the reason213.241(c)(6)
Total untested length and percentage of the runGood practice
4. Defects foundLocation: milepost, rail, position in a joint or weld if relevant213.241(c)(3)
Defect type in 213.113(d) terms213.241(c)(3)
Size in the units of the 213.113(c) table213.241(c)(4), if the rail stays in track
Sizing method and, for transverse defects, the head wear allowed forGood practice
Rail marked on both sides of web and base213.237(e) duty; recording it is good practice
5. Remedial action (owner)Initial remedial action and date for each defect213.241(c)(5)
Name of the 213.7 designated person who made the decisionGood practice
6. Operator and equipmentOperator name and 213.238 qualification for that equipment typeGood practice (213.238(e) record is the employer's)
Equipment identification; calibration checks with timesGood practice
7. Verified non-defectsIndications hand-verified and found not to be defectsGood practice
8. Sign-offOperator's certification; date and time storage was initiated213.241(j)(3) and (j)(5), if electronic

Sections 6 and 7 are the ones buyers leave out. Calibration is not a 213.241 item, but the calibration log is the evidence that each tested stretch was a valid search; our article on ultrasonic testing calibration for rail inspection lists what that log should show. Attach the layout to the scope of work. Our checklist for arranging hi-rail rail flaw testing covers the other items to settle before the crew arrives.

Key takeaway: put the six rule items in fixed fields, give the owner a field for item (5), and ask for calibration and non-defect lists by contract.

Worked example: checking a test report against 213.241(c)

The example below checks one stop-and-verify report for coverage, deadlines and retention. The numbers are invented for illustration.

Inputs. A Class 4 segment runs from milepost 12.00 to milepost 27.40 on a single main track. The last valid test was on February 20, 2026. Tonnage since then is under 30 million gross tons, so the 370-day limit controls. The new test runs on Tuesday, February 9, 2027, and the operator completes it at 3:30 p.m.

Step 1: coverage. The segment is 27.40 − 12.00 = 15.40 miles. The report lists three lengths without a valid search:

Untested lengthMilesReason given
MP 14.62 to 14.700.08Road crossing, contaminated rail surface
MP 19.95 to 20.000.05Heavy lubricant on the rail head
MP 26.10 to 26.130.03Equipment fault, one channel lost
Total0.16About 845 ft

Valid search: 15.40 − 0.16 = 15.24 miles, or 15.24 ÷ 15.40 = 99.0% of the segment. Item (6) is satisfied because each length is located.

Step 2: the deadline for the untested lengths. The 370-day limit from February 20, 2026 expires on February 25, 2027. The test took place 354 days after the last one, so 16 days remain. Before February 25, the owner must make a valid search of the three lengths, hold trains over them to 25 mph, or replace the rail (213.237(h)). A retest is a new inspection with its own record.

Step 3: defects. The report lists two defects.

DefectLocationSizeWhat happenedSize required by (c)(4)?
Detail fractureMP 16.31, north rail15% of existing head areaStays in track; remedial action C applied February 9, 2027Required
Bolt hole crackMP 22.07, south rail3/4 in.Rail replaced before the next train, February 9, 2027Not required, though worth recording

Both rows have item (5), entered by the owner's designated person.

Step 4: electronic storage. The inspection was completed at 3:30 p.m. on February 9, 2027. If the record is electronic, the person who made the inspection must initiate storage within 72 hours, by 3:30 p.m. on Friday, February 12, 2027.

Step 5: retention.

ConditionDate
Two years after the inspectionFebruary 9, 2029
One year after initial remedial action (February 9, 2027)February 9, 2028
Keep the record until at leastFebruary 9, 2029

Result. The report meets 213.241(c). The open item is the 0.16 mile of untested track, which has a 16-day clock.

Key takeaway: add up the untested lengths, date the deadline for them, and confirm that every defect row has a size where needed and a remedial action with a date.

What mistakes show up in rail inspection records?

Most record failures are omissions: the report describes what was found and leaves out what was not tested or what the owner did next.

  • No untested-track list. A report with defects but no item (6) entry implies full coverage that the operator may not have had.
  • Item (5) left blank. The contractor delivered the report before the owner acted, and nobody completed it.
  • Sizes in the wrong terms. A transverse defect given in inches cannot be matched to the remedial action table.
  • A completed record edited in place. Corrections belong in a separate, attributed amendment under (j)(6).
  • The contractor holds the only copy. Contracts end, and the retention duty is the owner's for two years.
  • Operator qualification assumed. 213.238(a) bars an owner from using a provider that has no documented training program, so ask for the 213.238(e) record first.

When a defect leads to a speed restriction, the remedial action record and the slow order have to agree. Our article on what happens when a rail defect is found follows that chain.

What 49 CFR 213.241 doesn't cover

49 CFR 213.241 sets minimum contents and retention; it does not prescribe a form, a test method or the supporting data behind the record.

  • No form. The section prescribes no rail test report format.
  • No calibration or raw data. Paragraph (c) does not list calibration records, A-scans or B-scans. An owner who wants them kept must say so in the contract.
  • No operator name in (c). Operator qualification records are a 213.238 duty of the employer.
  • No unverified indications. A stop-and-verify record lists defects found, not every indication checked and dismissed.
  • No later remedial history. Item (5) asks for the initial remedial action only.
  • Not all track. Paragraph (c) covers internal rail inspections "required by § 213.237", which reaches Class 3, 4 and 5 track. A voluntary test on Class 1 or 2 track is not a required inspection, though 213.113 still applies to any defect the owner learns of. Part 213 itself excludes plant railroads and rapid transit not connected to the general railroad system (213.3(b)); state safety oversight and the agency's own standards set the records there.
  • Not Class 6 to 9. Those records fall under 213.369.

Test intervals by track class are covered in how often rail must be tested.

How EMA Industries applies this

EMA Industries provides hyrail ultrasonic rail flaw detection and manual rail scanning for transit agencies, short lines and industrial track owners, with NDT Level III technical support. The company is based in Southern California and mobilizes for projects throughout the United States. Whoever tests your rail, ask for a report laid out against the six 213.241(c) items, with every untested length located and a field for your own remedial action entry, and ask for the operator qualification record before the test. To scope a rail testing program or a report format, see our ultrasonic rail testing services or contact EMA Industries.

Related reading: FRA track safety standards (Part 213) · 49 CFR 213.237 rail flaw detection requirements · Ultrasonic testing calibration for rail inspection · Arranging hi-rail rail flaw testing

Frequently asked questions

How long must rail flaw detection records be kept under 49 CFR 213.241?

At least two years after the inspection and one year after the initial remedial action, under 213.241(d). Both conditions apply, which in practice means two years from the test. Visual track inspection records have a one-year minimum under 213.241(b).

Who keeps the 213.241 record, the testing contractor or the track owner?

The track owner. Paragraph (a) places the duty on "each owner of track", and paragraph (d) says the track owner shall retain the rail inspection record. A contractor usually prepares most of it, but the owner must hold it and complete the remedial action entry.

Where do rail inspection records go once they are complete?

They stay with the track owner. Section 213.241(i) requires the owner to make records available for inspection and copying by FRA on request, during regular business hours and after reasonable notice. Nothing in the section requires routine filing with FRA.

What does "track not tested pursuant to § 213.237(g)" mean in a rail test report?

It means any length of track where the qualified operator decided a valid search for internal defects could not be made. Under 213.237(g) that length does not count as inspected, so the record must give its location, and the owner must retest it, limit trains to 25 mph or replace the rail before the test interval expires.

What makes a contractor's electronic report a compliant 213.241 record?

The six conditions of 213.241(j). The system must hold every required item, identify each author uniquely, lock the completed record and store amendments separately. The person who made the inspection must initiate storage within 72 hours, and the owner must monitor the database for accuracy.

Sources

← All articles