Welding Inspection

PAUT vs Radiography: When Phased Array UT Can Replace RT Under AWS D1.1 and ASME

Two running rails on concrete ties, each with a field weld visible where a bolted joint used to be, the kind of weld that is examined ultrasonically in track
Photo: Seamless welding rail tracks at Platform 3B, TRA Badu Station 20110222 by Solomon203, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped; this version is shared under the same license.

In the PAUT vs radiography decision, phased array ultrasonic testing can replace radiographic testing only where the governing code or the Engineer allows it. ASME Section VIII Division 1 offers ultrasonic examination as an alternative on welds 1/4 in. (6 mm) and thicker, while AWS D1.1 leaves the method to the contract documents and governs PAUT through Annex H.

A note on the sources. AWS D1.1, AWS D1.5 and the ASME codes are paywalled. Their clause numbers and limits below come from public summaries, a Federal Highway Administration report and regulations read on November 13, 2026, and each is marked where it needs confirming. Check every clause in the edition your contract names before you change an inspection specification.

PAUT vs radiography: what does each method find and miss?

Radiography images differences in material thickness along the beam, so it is strongest on volumetric flaws such as porosity and slag; phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT) reflects sound off surfaces, so it is strongest on planar flaws such as lack of fusion and cracks.

Radiographic testing (RT) passes X-rays or gamma rays through the weld onto film or a digital detector. A flaw shows only if it changes the amount of metal in the beam path. A 2024 Federal Highway Administration study of bridge welds states the consequence:

"Planar discontinuities like lack of fusion, and most cracks are only detectable by RT when the discontinuity plane aligns with the radiation beam." (FHWA-HRT-24-010, Implementation of Phased Array Ultrasonic Testing (PAUT) for Bridge Welds, February 2024, chapter 6)

PAUT is ultrasonic testing with a multi-element probe that steers the beam through a range of angles. A tight planar flaw that barely shows on film can return a strong echo if the beam meets it close to square, while a round pore scatters sound and returns a weak one.

TWI states both halves. On lack of fusion: "Ultrasonic inspection is normally more effective than radiography in detecting lack of inter-run fusion imperfections" (TWI Job Knowledge 41). On porosity: "Radiography is normally more effective in detecting and characterising porosity imperfections" (TWI Job Knowledge 42).

QuestionRadiography (RT)Phased array UT (PAUT)
What produces the indicationA change in metal thickness along the beamA reflecting surface the sound beam can reach
Porosity and slagStrong: shape is visible on the imageDetected, but harder to characterize
Lack of fusion and cracksFound only when the flaw plane lines up with the beam, or the gap is wideStrong when the scan plan puts a beam near square to the flaw
Depth of the flaw in the weldNot given by a single exposureGiven, with position across the weld
Flaw lengthMeasured on the imageMeasured from encoded data, usually by a 6 dB drop
AccessSource on one side, film or detector on the otherScanning surface on one face, normally both sides of the weld
RecordFilm or digital imageEncoded data file with A-scans
Site controlsRadiation boundary, licensed crewCouplant, surface preparation, no radiation boundary

The FHWA study adds the depth point in plain words: "the depth at which the discontinuities occur cannot be inferred using RT", while PAUT data "can be used to locate and size discontinuities".

PAUT sizing has its own caution. ASTM E2700-26, the practice for contact phased array testing of welds, warns in section 1.2.1 that "Extreme caution should be used when attempting to size indications using phased array", because beam spread can make an indication look larger than it is.

How the phased array beam is formed and steered is covered in our guide to phased array ultrasonic testing, and the wider method comparison is in the comparison of non-destructive testing methods.

Key takeaway: RT and PAUT answer different questions, so swapping one for the other changes which flaws the inspection is best at finding.

Can PAUT replace radiography under AWS D1.1?

AWS D1.1 does not choose the test method: the contract documents do, so PAUT can stand in for a radiographic test the contract specifies only if the Engineer agrees to the change, and the PAUT itself must then meet the code's phased array annex. No public summary of D1.1 that we found reports a clause letting a contractor make that swap alone.

D1.1, the structural steel welding code, requires visual inspection of every weld and sets acceptance criteria for magnetic particle, penetrant, radiographic and ultrasonic testing when the contract documents call for them. It has separate RT criteria and UT tables for statically and cyclically loaded connections. Our guide to the AWS D1.1 acceptance criteria explains how those tables work.

The 2020 edition added Annex H for phased array testing. A study reference for the 2025 edition quotes its opening line: "This annex provides mandatory requirements that shall apply when phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT) is used." Two public summaries, one from an instrument maker on the 2020 edition and one study reference on the 2025 edition, agree on the main conditions.

Annex H itemAs reported in public summaries (CONFIRM in your edition)
ScopeGroove welds and heat-affected zones, 3/16 in. to 8 in. (5 mm to 200 mm) thick, by encoded linear scanning
ExcludedTubular T-, Y- and K-connection welds
InstrumentAt least 16 pulsers and 16 channels; A-, B-, C- and S-scan views
Probe and wedgeLinear array of at least 16 elements, 1 to 6 MHz; shear waves between 40° and 70°
ScanningEncoded and recorded, with a written scan plan; a mockup check above 2 in. (50 mm)
SensitivityReference level set on the 0.060 in. (1.5 mm) side-drilled hole of an IIW-type block
AcceptanceNo planar indications; other indications classed by amplitude and limited by length in the annex tables; length by 6 dB drop
PersonnelUT Level II or III with 320 hours of PAUT experience and a practical examination on flawed specimens

Sources: Sonatest, "PAUT of Welds to 2020 AWS D1.1" (vendor, June 2023) and clause5.io on D1.1:2025 Annex H (study reference). Neither is the code text.

Both summaries describe Annex H as an alternative ultrasonic technique: it sits beside the code's conventional UT rules, and the study reference says variations from those rules "may be used only with the Engineer's approval". Neither summary reports any wording that treats PAUT as a replacement for a specified radiograph.

The practical route under D1.1 is therefore a request to the Engineer that names the welds, the reason, the Annex H procedure and the acceptance criteria that will apply, because the RT and PAUT criteria are not the same table.

Key takeaway: under D1.1 the Engineer decides the method, and Annex H decides how the phased array test is done.

What does the bridge welding code require, and what has FHWA found?

AWS D1.5, the bridge welding code, still requires radiography for complete joint penetration welds in tension or stress reversal, and FHWA's 2024 research supports PAUT as a candidate replacement without yet recommending it outright. D1.5 applies to steel bridges designed to AASHTO or AREMA requirements, so it reaches railroad bridges as well as highway ones (AASHTO/AWS D1.5M/D1.5:2025 product page).

The FHWA report sets out the code position. The code "requires RT for CJP welds subjected to tensile or reversal stresses", and for butt joints in compression or shear "either RT or UT shall be used". It also records that "In the 2015 edition of AWS D1.5, the PAUT technique was acknowledged as a recognized inspection technology for use instead of conventional UT on CJP butt welds." That is recognition as a form of UT, not as a substitute for RT.

To test the substitute question, FHWA's laboratory inspected 10 welded specimens with PAUT, conventional UT and RT, including electroslag welds in plate up to 3.3 in. thick (FHWA-HRT-24-010, ROSA P record).

Result (FHWA-HRT-24-010, 10 specimens)Figure
Correlation of flaw length, RT against PAUT0.89
Correlation of flaw length, conventional UT against PAUT0.91
Correlation of flaw depth, conventional UT against PAUT0.95
Discontinuities rejected by RT that PAUT accepted or missed4
Lack-of-fusion discontinuities PAUT detected that RT missed3
Discontinuities PAUT rejected that RT accepted1

The report calls the correlation strong and attributes most disagreements on accept or reject to "the differences in acceptance criteria utilized in RT and PAUT". Its conclusion is measured: the results give "substantial support" for PAUT as an alternative to radiography, but a wider set of flaw types, welding processes, thicknesses and joint types is needed before RT can be fully replaced.

An earlier Florida DOT study reached a similar view. Wilkinson and Duke (University of South Florida, 2014) compared RT, UT and PAUT on bridge welds to D1.5 and concluded that "PAUT would make a suitable substitute for RT (and UT) in bridge weld inspection" with an appropriate procedure (report BDK84-977-26, ROSA P record).

Both are research findings. On a bridge contract the tension butt welds stay with RT unless the owner's specification says otherwise.

Key takeaway: for bridge welds the evidence favors PAUT, but the code's RT requirement for tension welds has not been replaced.

When does ASME allow ultrasonic examination in lieu of radiography?

ASME Section VIII Division 1 allows ultrasonic examination as an alternative to required radiography on welds where the thinner member is 1/4 in. (6 mm) or more, on the condition that the examination follows the Division 2 rules for recorded, automated or semi-automated UT. A manual scan with a phased array instrument does not meet that condition as public sources describe it.

The route started as a code case. Code Case 2235 allowed UT in lieu of RT for pressure vessel and boiler welds with a demonstrated procedure and recorded data. Revision 2235-9 (October 2005) is the one most often cited. Evident, an instrument maker, notes that the requirements have since been written into the code books themselves.

CodeWhere the UT alternative sits, as reported (CONFIRM)Main conditions
Section VIII Division 1 (pressure vessels)UW-51(a)(4), carried out under UW-53(b)Thinner member 1/4 in. (6 mm) or more; examined and evaluated to Division 2, paragraph 7.5.5
Section VIII Division 2Paragraph 7.5.5Automated or semi-automated UT to a written procedure under Section V, Article 4, Mandatory Appendix VIII; the manufacturer reviews and accepts the scan data
B31.3 (process piping)Para. 341.4.1(b)(1)Random examination of girth welds by RT under 344.5 or UT under 344.6; Appendix R adds acceptance criteria for techniques that size flaws
B31.1 (power piping)Mandatory examination tables"Volumetric examination, which could be radiographic or ultrasonic examination"

Sources: a 2026 engineering summary of the 2025 edition for the 1/4 in. limit (Kezar Engineering); a 2019 NDT.net forum quotation of UW-53(b) and 7.5.5; and a 2026 article by T. R. Hay for B31.1 (OneStopNDT). The B31.3 row comes from earlier research for our ASME weld ultrasonic inspection guide.

Three conditions matter to an owner or fabricator:

  1. The data must be recorded. The examination is encoded, so every A-scan is stored with its position and can be reviewed later.
  2. The acceptance criteria change. UT in lieu of RT is judged by flaw size rules written for it, not by the radiographic limits.
  3. The procedure is demonstrated. Public descriptions of the code case and of Division 2 call for a written procedure proven on a block with known flaws.

ASME Section V itself only says how to examine. It "contains requirements and methods for nondestructive examination which are referenced and required by other BPVC Sections", and acceptance comes from the construction code. The acceptance side is set out in our article on UT acceptance criteria and standards.

Key takeaway: ASME has a written route from RT to UT, and it runs through encoded data, a demonstrated procedure and UT-specific acceptance criteria.

Why do owners switch from radiography to phased array?

The reasons owners give are the radiation controls around field radiography, the depth information PAUT adds for repairs, and a data record that can be reviewed like a film.

Gamma radiography with sealed sources is licensed under 10 CFR Part 34 by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission or an Agreement State. Part 34 covers sealed gamma sources; X-ray machines generally fall under state radiation control programs. Five rules bear directly on a field job.

RuleWhat it requires
10 CFR 34.41(a)Away from a permanent radiographic installation, the radiographer must be accompanied by at least one other qualified radiographer or an individual who meets the 34.43(c) training requirements
10 CFR 34.43(a)A radiographer needs training, at least 2 months of on-the-job training, and certification through a certifying entity
10 CFR 34.47(a)Each radiographer and assistant wears a direct reading dosimeter, an operating alarm ratemeter and a personnel dosimeter
10 CFR 34.51One of the two must "maintain continuous direct visual surveillance of the operation to protect against unauthorized entry into a high radiation area"
10 CFR 34.53Areas where radiography is performed must be conspicuously posted

The two-person rule is blunt:

"Radiography may not be performed if only one qualified individual is present." (10 CFR 34.41(a))

Behind the boundary sits the public dose limit. Under 10 CFR 20.1301(a)(2), the dose in any unrestricted area from external sources may not exceed "0.002 rem (0.02 millisievert) in any one hour". Everyone who is not part of the radiography crew has to be outside the line where that could happen, so exposures are scheduled for times when the area can be cleared.

PAUT has none of these controls, so other trades can keep working beside the technician. The FHWA report notes that using RT "in an industrial or laboratory setup gives rise to a variety of radiation regulatory and safety issues".

Replacing film with a digital detector does not remove the source. Computed radiography (ASTM E2033) and digital detector arrays (ASTM E2698) change how the image is captured, but the exposure still needs the same licensed crew and boundary.

No public figure reliably compares the price of the two methods, so this article gives none. The cost drivers are visible in the rules: two qualified people, a cleared area, and the hours other trades cannot work.

Key takeaway: the case for switching rests on federal radiation rules and repair information, not on a claim that PAUT finds more.

Worked example: how large is the boundary for a field gamma exposure?

A simple inverse-square estimate shows why an unshielded iridium-192 exposure can clear a work site for hundreds of feet. The inputs are illustrative, and a licensee sets real boundaries by survey.

Inputs. An iridium-192 source of 60 curies. A source maker's data sheet gives the output as 5.2 R/hr per curie at 1 ft (QSA Global, Ir-192 sealed sources; vendor data). No collimator and no credit for shielding by the steel. One roentgen of gamma exposure is taken as one rem of dose.

Step 1: the rate at 1 ft. 60 × 5.2 = 312 R/hr.

Step 2: distance to a given dose rate. The rate falls with the square of the distance, so distance = √(312 ÷ rate limit), with both in R/hr.

Dose rate while the source is exposedWhy it mattersDistance
100 mrem/hr (0.1 R/hr)High radiation area level in 10 CFR 20.1003; the area 34.51 says must be kept under watch√(312 ÷ 0.1) = 55.9 ft
5 mrem/hr (0.005 R/hr)Radiation area level in 10 CFR 20.1003√(312 ÷ 0.005) = 249.8 ft
2 mrem/hr (0.002 R/hr)Public limit of 20.1301(a)(2) if the source stayed exposed for the whole hour√(312 ÷ 0.002) = 395.0 ft

Step 3: allow for exposure time. The 20.1301 limit is a dose in any one hour. If the source is out of its shield for 15 minutes in the hour, the dose at any point is one quarter of the hourly rate. The boundary becomes √(312 × 0.25 ÷ 0.002) = 197.5 ft, and a circle of that radius covers π × 197.5² = about 122,500 sq ft, or 2.8 acres.

Step 4: an older source. Iridium-192 has a half-life of 74 days, so after 74 days the source is 30 curies and the rate at 1 ft is 156 R/hr. If each exposure now takes twice as long to give the same image, the source is out for 30 minutes in the hour, and the boundary is √(156 × 0.5 ÷ 0.002) = 197.5 ft again. For the same number of exposures an hour, a weaker source does not shrink the hourly boundary.

What the example leaves out. A collimator, which 10 CFR 34.3 defines as a shield that restricts the size of the radiation beam, cuts the dose outside the beam, and steel in the path absorbs part of it: the same maker lists a half-value layer of about 0.5 in. of steel for iridium-192. The real line is set and confirmed by survey under the licensee's procedures. The arithmetic shows the scale: tens of feet for the watched area and hundreds of feet for the public boundary, against none for PAUT.

Key takeaway: with these inputs the public boundary is about 200 ft in every direction, which is the schedule cost a switch to PAUT removes.

Which method fits which job?

Choose by the flaw that matters most, the code route available and the site, in that order.

SituationBetter fitWhy
Thick butt welds where lack of fusion or cracking is the concernPAUTPlanar flaws reflect sound well and may not align with a radiation beam
Welds where porosity or slag must be characterizedRTVolumetric flaws show their shape on the image
Material thinner than the UT alternative allows (below 1/4 in. under ASME Section VIII, or 3/16 in. under D1.1 Annex H as reported)RTThe code alternative is not available
D1.5 bridge butt welds in tension or reversalRT, unless the owner approves otherwiseThe code still requires it
Field work in an occupied plant or on a short shutdownPAUT, where the code route existsNo radiation boundary; other trades keep working
Only one side of the weld can be reached for scanningCase by casePAUT coverage normally needs both sides; RT needs the far side for the film
Repairs where excavation depth must be knownPAUTGives depth and position across the weld
Coarse-grained or austenitic weldsCase by caseUltrasound scatters in coarse grain; the procedure must be demonstrated on the material
Tubular T-, Y- and K-connections under D1.1Not Annex HReported as excluded from the annex

For the equipment a contractor should bring to a recorded examination, see our guide to phased array ultrasonic testing equipment.

What should a PAUT procedure used in place of RT contain?

A procedure that replaces a radiograph has to show three things on paper before the first scan: the permission, the coverage and the acceptance criteria.

  1. The code route and the approval. The clause relied on (Annex H under D1.1, UW-51(a)(4) under Section VIII Division 1, or the piping paragraph), the edition, and the Engineer's or owner's written approval.
  2. A scan plan for each joint geometry. Probe, wedge, angle range, offsets from the weld centerline and a coverage drawing. FHWA found that thick butt welds needed "multiple scans along each side of the weld at different probe index point offsets" for full volume coverage.
  3. Encoded scanning and data storage. The encoder check, the recording increment, the file format and how long the data are kept.
  4. Calibration. The reference block and reflector, time-corrected gain across the angle range, and the checks during the shift.
  5. Acceptance criteria named separately from the technique. ASTM E2700 and ASME Section V Article 4 say how to examine. The annex tables, the construction code or the contract say what to reject.
  6. Sizing method. How length and height are measured, with the ASTM E2700 caution on oversizing in mind.
  7. Demonstration. The block or mockup, the flaws in it, and who witnessed the demonstration.
  8. Personnel. Employer certification in UT with the PAUT-specific training, hours and examination the code or annex requires.
  9. What happens where the scanner cannot reach. Edges, transitions and obstructions, and the supplementary technique used there.

The difference between a phased array instrument used by hand and a recorded examination is covered in the difference between UT and PAUT.

Key takeaway: if the request to drop RT does not include a scan plan and named acceptance criteria, it is not ready to approve.

Does any of this apply to rail welds?

Rail welds in track are not made or accepted to AWS D1.1 or the ASME codes, so the UT-in-lieu-of-RT routes above do not govern them. Thermite and flash-butt weld acceptance comes from the track owner's specification and supplier procedures, with AREMA recommended practice and, where adopted, AWS D15.2.

In-track rail testing is already ultrasonic. Rail test vehicles and hand units use fixed-angle probes, and phased array is not established as routine in-track practice in published sources. The site's article on PAUT vs TOFD for rail weld inspection covers that evidence, and the aluminothermic weld inspection guide covers field weld testing.

The railway work where the RT question does arise is structural: steel railroad bridges fabricated to D1.5 and building steel to D1.1.

What PAUT can't do in place of radiography

PAUT is not a like-for-like replacement for radiography: it is weaker on some flaws, has thickness and geometry limits, and depends more on the scan plan and the analyst.

  • Volumetric flaws. Porosity and slag are detected but are harder to characterize than on a radiograph.
  • Thin material. The reported UT alternatives start at 1/4 in. (ASME Section VIII Division 1) and 3/16 in. (D1.1 Annex H), and ASTM E2700 is written mainly for 9 mm to 200 mm.
  • Coverage is designed, not automatic. A sector scan from one position does not cover every weld volume. The scan plan has to prove it.
  • Sizing. Amplitude-based sizing can oversize, as ASTM E2700 warns, and a flaw shorter than the beam width measures as the beam width.
  • Different criteria give different answers. In the FHWA comparison, four discontinuities rejected by RT were accepted or missed by PAUT, and one went the other way. Changing the method changes some accept and reject decisions.
  • Surface and access. The scanning surface must be prepared and the probe must travel the weld length, normally on both sides.
  • People. The data still have to be analyzed by a trained person, and analysis can take longer than the scan.
  • Permission. None of the technical points matter if the code or the Engineer has not allowed the change.

Where both methods struggle, such as tight lack of fusion at an unfavorable angle, see our article on lack of fusion in welds.

How EMA Industries applies this

EMA Industries provides AWS D1.1 structural weld UT, magnetic particle and liquid penetrant testing, rail weld inspection and NDT Level III technical support from Southern California, and mobilizes for projects throughout the United States. For an owner or fabricator weighing a change from radiography, Level III support means review of the PAUT procedure and scan plan: the code route, the coverage drawings, the calibration, and whether the technique and acceptance documents are named separately. To discuss a weld inspection scope or a procedure review, see our ultrasonic examination services or contact EMA Industries.

Related reading: Phased array ultrasonic testing · AWS D1.1 acceptance criteria · ASME weld ultrasonic inspection · Phased array ultrasonic testing equipment · AWS D1.1 visual inspection checklist

Frequently asked questions

Is PAUT better than radiography for weld inspection?

It depends on the flaw. PAUT is normally stronger on planar flaws such as lack of fusion and cracks, and it gives flaw depth. Radiography is normally stronger at detecting and characterizing porosity and slag.

Does AWS D1.1 allow PAUT instead of RT?

D1.1 lets the contract documents set the test method and, since the 2020 edition, governs phased array testing through Annex H. Public summaries describe the annex as an alternative ultrasonic technique. Replacing a specified radiograph with PAUT therefore needs the Engineer's approval.

What thickness is needed for UT in lieu of RT under ASME Section VIII?

Public summaries of Section VIII Division 1 give 1/4 in. (6 mm) for the thinner member joined, under UW-51(a)(4). Older revisions of Code Case 2235 used larger minimums. Confirm the figure in the edition your vessel is built to.

Why does radiography need two people on site?

Under 10 CFR 34.41(a), radiography away from a permanent installation requires a second qualified individual who observes the operation and can give immediate assistance to prevent unauthorized entry. The rule states that radiography may not be performed if only one qualified individual is present.

Can a hand-held phased array scan replace a radiograph?

Under the ASME route, public sources describe the alternative as automated or semi-automated UT with recorded data, which a free-hand scan does not provide. Under D1.1 Annex H, encoded scanning is the reported rule, with limited exceptions at edges and corners. In both cases the recorded data stand in for the film.

Sources

← All articles